London Tribunal Rejects Nearly £2 Billion Class Action Over PlayStation Store Prices

Sony has defeated one of Britain’s largest consumer class actions, after a London tribunal threw out in full a claim worth almost £2 billion (about $2.6 billion) that accused the company of inflating the price of digital games.

The Decision

The Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claim on Tuesday, November 17, following a trial that began in March. It concluded that the class of claimants had not established that Sony broke competition law, according to Reuters reporting.

What the Claimants Alleged

The case argued that Sony abused a dominant market position by requiring digital games and add-on content for its console to be sold only through the PlayStation Store. Because no rival storefront could compete, the claimants said, Sony could set retail prices without pressure and earn what their lawyers called monopoly profits, leaving digital titles costlier than physical copies.

Sony’s Defense

Sony told the tribunal it had spent years and billions of dollars building an integrated gaming platform that benefits consumers in a market where Nintendo and Microsoft’s Xbox use similar models. Its lawyers described the lawsuit as, in effect, an argument that outside companies should be allowed to open their own stores on PlayStation and “free-ride” on that investment. They also said the margin Sony earns on games and add-ons is not excessive and that the claim ignored the company’s costs and the value of its brand.

After the ruling, Sony Interactive Entertainment’s general counsel, Stephanie Burns, said the outcome affirms the company’s business model.

A Test for Britain’s Class Action Regime

The case was the third against a major technology company to reach trial since the start of 2025, as the United Kingdom’s class-action-style system for competition claims gathers pace. The results so far have been mixed. The tribunal ruled against Apple over its App Store last year, and Apple is seeking to appeal. A case against chipmaker Qualcomm was withdrawn after trial but before a ruling. A trial of a lawsuit against Google began in October, although Epic Games withdrew its claim after Google announced sweeping changes to its Play Store practices.

The Sony loss is a setback for claimants and funders who have bet on large collective actions against platform owners. It also signals that showing a company controls its own store is not the same as proving that its pricing is unlawful, a gap the tribunal found the claimant class could not bridge here.

Sources